Thursday, November 12, 2026

Numbers with Personality Response

This reading (predictably) got me thinking about how I see each number. There are three things I realized after thinking about it.

The first is that, although I don’t have any very set idea of a personification, colour, or other association with each number I do have a strong sense for weather or not I agree with those that others come up with when they tell me about them. I have before had people tell me that they associate certain numbers with specific things in different categories (colours, seasons, subjects in school personality’s, genders, etc.). if someone were to ask me to say which number went with which colour I could kind of, do it (8 is orange, 7 is green) but not completely and not with certainty (I’m not sure which colour 5 is and I believe 6 is blue but this is because 6 is my favorite number and blue is my favorite colour. Not because (and I know this likely does not make sense to anyone other than myself) 6 actually is blue). However, when other people tell me the associations they have between numbers and other things I always have a strong sense for whether I agree or disagree.


The second is a less abstract mental interpretation of the numbers that is very strongly ingrained in my head. Each number when written, in my handwriting, has a very specific placement for its number of dots overtop of it. Except for 9, I am not sure why, perhaps it would be too many dots and therefore my brain decided to skip it. This is almost always how I count unless I am using my fingers. If I am counting 6 my finger will normally tap 6 times as I imagine the number and then imagine hitting the dots on it. If I add 7 to 7, I will start with 7 and then count 8,9,10 as I “hit” the three dots on the smaller line in 7 and then 11,12,13,14 as I “hit” the three dots on the longer line.

 

The third is that as ai mentioned before 6 is my favorite number. So, although I don’t have personifications for each number I very strongly associate 6 with myself. If someone were to tell me that their personification of 6 was unflattering, I believe I would take it personally. Interestingly, 6 is not a number that has any relevance to my identity beyond being my favorite, it is not a part of my birthday or the number of people in my family or something else like that. It is only my favorite because of a guessing game I played in elementary school (it’s a slightly longer but not very interesting story I won’t tell all of here). So, I was interested to realize how completely I had incorporated it into my identity given that it did not become my favorite by way of already being a part of my identity.

Saturday, October 17, 2026

Egyptian Wall Painting Response

 Before reading the article, here is what I noticed: 

-       At the top of the painting, they seem to be using rope with evenly spaced knots to measure the field.

-       The bottom of the painting seems to depict counting the volume of grain collected. I interpret what’s happening as taking buckets of grain from one pile and pouring them into another pile. Someone is noting things and I would assume they are counting how many buckets of grain they have to be able to know the total volume.


Here are my thoughts after reading the article:

It seems like I was pretty accurate in guessing what was going on in the painting at least in the top part. What I’m curious about from this article is where the distances of measurements they had in ancient Egypt came from. Particularly I am interested in where the distance associated with a palm and a finger came from. Given that these have the same names as parts of the body it seems like it would make sense for them to have come from using fingers to measure things. However, the measurements the article gives don’t seem like they would match up with most actual people’s bodies. So, I’m curious where they came from. Was it that at some point Egyptians were using their fingers to measure things and so when they made a more standardized unit, they kept the name finger? If so,
how did they decide on the distance of the more standardized unit?

 

I was also interested to learn that in some cases the measurements for buildings were done by priests when they had religious meanings. It makes me wonder what training an Egyptian priest would have and how it would overlap with a surveyors training. Id also be curious to know when it was decided that a priest should be the one doing the measurements rather than a surveyor, was it just that priests had to do measurements related to the stars? If so, how was this enforced? Was it a cultural expectation or were there strict rules around it?

Tuesday, October 6, 2026

Ancient Problem Project Personal Reflection

The main thing I learned from working through the modern and ancient solutions to our problems is how hard it can be to see different kinds of math given that I always approach math in the ways I was taught. Even once we had some ideas for our ancient solution to our problem it was challenging to put ourselves in the shoes of an ancient Babylonian. Knowing if a solution was actually something that would have been done in ancient Babylon was challenging. It really made me realize how far removed I am from mathematical contexts other than my own. Even though math can be done in many ways the modern way of doing is so ingrained in me that, understanding what would have and could have been done using other systems was a challenge.

Additionally, this project taught me about how much bigger things like multiplication tables are when using a base 60 system. I was of course vaguely aware of this before starting the project however trying to find ways of multiplying and dividing by 6 made it very clear just how impractical a full base 60 multiplication table would be. In the modern context using tricks instead of straight memorization of times tables is common but not strictly necessary. However, for ancient Babylonians these tricks were completely necessary because of the size of there base. Realizing this made me realize that having a different base doesn’t just mean slightly different calculations being done it also means that the way of seeing math is different.

Sunday, October 4, 2026

Deriving the Babylonian 6 Times Table

Our problem was to “try and discover and formulate rules for multiplying by 6 and dividing by 6 in the sexagesimal system.” The first ancient solution we considered was using multiplication tables. Given a table of 6 multiplied by 1 – 19, 20, 30, 40, and 50 an ancient Babylonian could use addition to find the solution to 6 multiplied by any number between 1 and 60. Similarly the Babylonians had reciprocal tables that could be used for division by 6. 

We also found a trick that ancient Babylonians could have used to multiply and divide by 6. To multiply a number by 6 you could divide the number by 10 and then shift the result one place to the left (this shift is equivalent to multiplying by 60). For dividing you can multiply the number by 10 and then shift the answer one place to the right (equivalent to dividing by 60).

The modern way we solved this problem for both multiplication and division was to convert the problem to base ten and then do the multiplication or division in base 10. Once that is done you can convert it back. Once the problem is in base 10, we can use any modern strategies we would like to solve the problem.

We extended this problem by attempting to apply the solutions we found to a different number. The number we chose was 10. Both the ancient solution of using tables and reciprocals and the modern solution of converting to base 10 could be used the exact same way for 10 as they can for 6. We had to modify the ancient trick of using shifting to make it work for 10. To multiply by 10, you need to divide by 6 and then shift the solution to the left. To divide you need to multiply by 6 and then shift the solution to the right.  

 

 

 

 

 

Saturday, September 26, 2026

The Market Scales Puzzle

I did not end up solving this problem. Here is what I tried:

First, I looked at all the different ways 4 numbers could be placed on 4 scales, and it seems like there is only one way to make 40 unique numbers when you start with 4. 

Then I thought about Egyptian multiplication. I tried doubling to make 40 and the numbers that were used are 1, 2, 4, 8, 16, 32. Then I tried to find a combination of 4 of these that could be used. I knew 1 would have to be one of the numbers so I could make odd (I wrote even on my page but meant odd) numbers. And I knew 32 would have to be one so I could make large enough numbers. 32+16=48 which is larger than 40 so assuming I was right that each way of adding and subtracting the numbers (that doesn’t produce a negative number) needs to be 1 – 40, 16 could not be one of the numbers. So, I looked at all the ways 1, 2, 3, 4, and 32 could be used to make 1 – 40 to see if I could figure out what the final 4 numbers would be.

I wasn’t able to make 16 however with these 5 numbers and I did not find a obvious way that 4 numbers could make 1 – 4 using this.

Some ways I could have went wrong are that it seems that either I was wrong that there are only unique ways to combine 4 numbers or, I should not be using the doubles as the numbers. If it is true that there are only 40 ways to combine 4 numbers then the largest number would be a+b+c+d so a+b+c+d would need to equal 40 but there is no combination of 1 ,2 ,4, 8, 16 and 32 that includes 4 numbers and adds up to 40. Beyond this there are lots of combinations of these numbers that repeat (16-8=8 but you already have 8 on its own same with 8-4=4, 4-2=2, and 2-1=1). So either my guess that I should be using doubles was wrong or my logic in determining how 4 numbers a, b, c, d could be combined was wrong.

Despite this I did find this to be an interesting exercise, and I feel that I understand the Egyptian way of adding doubles to create any number better. Specifically adding the doubles to get 1 – 15 made it really clear how they are essentially binary.



Friday, September 25, 2026

Word Problems Reading Response

This article spends a lot of time discussing pure vs. applied math and how the form that questions are written in may not be enough to fully determine whether it is a pure or applied question. It seems that the reason Babylonians used questions that appeared to be about practical math to ask non practical or more abstract problems was because these word problems were how they expressed all math. However, the ancient Greeks were able to express their pure math problems using symbolic notation which we would consider to be a more “pure math” way of writing these problems. We however, often use word problems in classrooms even when the topic we are discussing is not an applied math topic despite the fact that we, unlike the Babylonians, do not express all math problems in this way.

I think one of the main motivations behind creating word problems that are phrased as if they are something that could happen in real life but, that are actually so removed from reality that they are simply pure math problems is that teachers are trying to prove that what is taught in a math class is relevant to their students. I am not sure if this is the best way to prove relevance. We often feel the need to tie everything that is taught in a math classroom to a real-life skill. In the case where what we are teaching is something students will actually be able to use and apply in there day to day lives I think it is an excellent idea to highlight this fact. However, when what we are teaching is less applicable to day-to-day life I think that the creation of word problems that attempt to tie the content to real life without actually addressing a situation that would ever actually happen is not useful. I feel it would be much better to be honest with students. If the only reason students are ever given for learning math is that they will need it for day-to-day life I think we are not letting them realize the full value of the subject. Not every student will develop an appreciation for the beauty of math, nor will every student want to study math beyond school. However, exposing them to the fact that math is beautiful and interesting all on its own without practical application and that it is something they may want to continue to take interest in once they leave school seems to me to be valuable. Even though not every student enjoys art we do not tell them that they will need it for day-to-day life, instead we tell them that creativity and beauty are important on their own. I think when we teach subjects in math that won’t be relevant to the majority of students beyond the interest, they invoke that we should be honest about that. Instead of trying to tie everything to practical applications we should try and highlight how math can be inherently valuable on its own. 

Tuesday, September 22, 2026

Did Mesopotamian scribes have algebra? Response

Reading about the difference between how ancient Babylonians communicated math compared to how we do now made me question what the value of our current, symbol heavy, system is. The main thing that I believe makes our current system useful is readability. So long as someone knows how notation and mathematical symbols are used, a problem that would be a dense word problem using rhetorical algebra can be simplified to a more readable and arguably more simple equation. However, the trade-off here is that as we move away from a rhetorical way of expressing math it can be easy to lose the context and motivation behind the math. I could however foresee a situation where this disadvantage could become useful. I think the loss of context could be made into an advantage in a teamwork context. For a more technically complicated project it could be useful to have someone who is able to solve the math once it has been symbolized but who doesn’t necessarily need to know the potentially technically complex context behind it.


That being said when I consider the differences between rhetorical algebra and our modern system that is heavily based on symbols from an educational lens, I find some problems with our modern system. The heavy use of symbols makes it easy for kids to memorize, not understand what they are supposed to do to solve a question. Because symbols can be almost entirely taken out of the original context of a problem it becomes easy for kids to focus on the steps they’ve memorized to complete a question and not on understanding what the question is about and how it relates to the math they are learning. In this way I can see how the ancient Babylonian system may have been better. Students who only ever worked with rhetorical algebra may have had a stronger understanding of the math they learnt. Despite this I still wouldn’t argue that a system that only uses rhetorical algebra is best. I think there are times when rhetorical algebra is preferable but also times where symbols are a powerful and useful tool.

Numbers with Personality Response

This reading (predictably) got me thinking about how I see each number. There are three things I realized after thinking about it. The first...