Saturday, September 26, 2026

The Market Scales Puzzle

I did not end up solving this problem. Here is what I tried:

First, I looked at all the different ways 4 numbers could be placed on 4 scales, and it seems like there is only one way to make 40 unique numbers when you start with 4. 

Then I thought about Egyptian multiplication. I tried doubling to make 40 and the numbers that were used are 1, 2, 4, 8, 16, 32. Then I tried to find a combination of 4 of these that could be used. I knew 1 would have to be one of the numbers so I could make odd (I wrote even on my page but meant odd) numbers. And I knew 32 would have to be one so I could make large enough numbers. 32+16=48 which is larger than 40 so assuming I was right that each way of adding and subtracting the numbers (that doesn’t produce a negative number) needs to be 1 – 40, 16 could not be one of the numbers. So, I looked at all the ways 1, 2, 3, 4, and 32 could be used to make 1 – 40 to see if I could figure out what the final 4 numbers would be.

I wasn’t able to make 16 however with these 5 numbers and I did not find a obvious way that 4 numbers could make 1 – 4 using this.

Some ways I could have went wrong are that it seems that either I was wrong that there are only unique ways to combine 4 numbers or, I should not be using the doubles as the numbers. If it is true that there are only 40 ways to combine 4 numbers then the largest number would be a+b+c+d so a+b+c+d would need to equal 40 but there is no combination of 1 ,2 ,4, 8, 16 and 32 that includes 4 numbers and adds up to 40. Beyond this there are lots of combinations of these numbers that repeat (16-8=8 but you already have 8 on its own same with 8-4=4, 4-2=2, and 2-1=1). So either my guess that I should be using doubles was wrong or my logic in determining how 4 numbers a, b, c, d could be combined was wrong.

Despite this I did find this to be an interesting exercise, and I feel that I understand the Egyptian way of adding doubles to create any number better. Specifically adding the doubles to get 1 – 15 made it really clear how they are essentially binary.



1 comment:

  1. Your reflection made me think about how much learning can happen even when we don't reach the final answer. You identified several assumptions in your reasoning and started questioning them. I wonder how we can create a classroom environment where students feel comfortable sharing this kind of unfinished thinking rather than focusing only on getting the correct answer.

    ReplyDelete

Numbers with Personality Response

This reading (predictably) got me thinking about how I see each number. There are three things I realized after thinking about it. The first...